Jump to content
SASS Wire Forum

Most Realistic Western Attire In a Film ...And Not.


Ben Bitten

Recommended Posts

Posted

I was watching The Outlaw Josey Wales a couple of nights ago and I got to ponderin'... What's some of the most realistic western attire seen in film? And What's not?

 

Off the top of my head I'd say:

Open Range

Wyatt Earp

3:10 to Yuma

Deadwood

 

As far as Not:

The Magnificent Seven. As much as I love the film, I've always had a bit of a problem with the attire - especially Vin... he look's like a contemporary cowboy. Especially with his faded Levi's.

 

I could add more to my lists but it's late and my brain ain't workin' right.

Posted

I was watching The Outlaw Josey Wales a couple of nights ago and I got to ponderin'... What's some of the most realistic western attire seen in film? And What's not?

 

Off the top of my head I'd say:

Open Range

Wyatt Earp

3:10 to Yuma

Deadwood

 

As far as Not:

The Magnificent Seven. As much as I love the film, I've always had a bit of a problem with the attire - especially Vin... he look's like a contemporary cowboy. Especially with his faded Levi's.

 

I could add more to my lists but it's late and my brain ain't workin' right.

 

Tombstone.. but Deadwood I liked their costumes the best. I have a photo of a painting some place of Pauline (ancestor) with her gown and hat really bright, its so pretty. But they did seem to wear dark colors a lot.. I suppose it didn't show the dirt so much.

Posted

Tombstone!......very colorful.

 

 

Posted

Ride with the Devil

Posted

And as far as Not Realistic:

 

Any Roy, Gene, or TV western episode. ;)

Guest Tennessee Stud, SASS# 43634 Life
Posted

Conagher

 

 

 

ts

Posted

I liked the way Noah Beery Jr. looked as Buster in "Red River"...a classic cowboy for sure.

 

For non-historical, mebbe Kid Shelleen's brother with the iron nose in "Cat Ballou", or Shelleen himself all dressed up?

Posted

Bandidas & Hannie Calder.

 

I thunk this thread wuz on "costuming" . . . if it wuz on "lack of costuming" . . then yep . . Bandidas & Hannie Clder are gud uns INDEED . . . :excl::)

Posted

Loved the attire in Appaloosa

Posted

Is that Maddog McCoy? :lol::lol::P

Now, That's funny!

Posted

Like Dejas Vous says: Tombstone and Deadwood have my vote...

 

include Lonesome Dove too ;)

 

GG ~ :FlagAm:

 

 

 

+ 1 ;)

Posted

Good:

Most of the made-for-TV weseterns since 1985, especiallyy the Turner stuff: Conagher, Sabine River, Open Range, Lonesome Dove, Monte Walsh

Several Duke Wayne movies: The Big Trail, the Searchers, The Shootist.

 

Less-than-good:

TV westerns up to How the West was Won (1970's) (The worst was Wild, Wild West)

B-Westerns of the 1930 to 1960.

Posted

The most authentic civil war movie (clothing, weapons, activities, dialog, etc) I've ever seen is "Ride With the Devil"! Agree with Utah Bob! Most likely this is how it really was. As for non-CW westerns, if I watch a western and don't notice modern costuming I'm happy. The first version of "True Grit" was a John Wayne movie so I didn't expect authenticity. John Wayne dressed like John Wayne and that's fine. The second version was an adaptation of the book and was very auithentic in costuming (with the exception of Rooster's hat) and i loved it

 

The O'Meara Himself

Posted

Lee Marvin in just about anything but especially in Liberty Valance. Lee must of demanded extra in his wardrobe cause he looked authentic right down to the fancy quirt. Now thats something you don't often see in movies despite the fact that dang near every cowboy/horseman/mounted indian warrior had one.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.