Snake-eye, SASS#45097 95 Posted May 10 Share Posted May 10 I may have to replace the brass carrier on my .44 rifle before to long. Debating an aluminum one vs. a skeltonized brass which is what’s in there now. Looking for opinions and experiences. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
evil dogooder 1,079 Posted May 10 Share Posted May 10 I've not made any in .44 so can't expound on that. However I've made .357 out of brass, aluminum, titanium, stainless, delron.. sp?, as well as several different alloys. What are you looking to get out of it? Aluminum will be lighter but unless hard coated it will wear a ton faster. I usually will swap mine out about every 20k I do have a new type of hard coat that is running over 40k with minimal wear. Brass has less issues over all to me. Lightened makes it close to aluminum in weight but stronger. My recommendation. Stick with brass 3 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Colorado Coffinmaker 3,899 Posted May 10 Share Posted May 10 PLUS ONE to the DoGooder. 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Springfield Slim SASS #24733 805 Posted May 11 Share Posted May 11 "Lightened makes it close to aluminum in weight but stronger" Could you quote us some actual weights of your brass and aluminum carriers? I have 2 aluminum and 3 lightened brass and I can't see where you could remove enough brass to get them close to being the same in weight. 2 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Caboose 154 Posted May 11 Share Posted May 11 (edited) 11 hours ago, Springfield Slim SASS #24733 said: "Lightened makes it close to aluminum in weight but stronger" Could you quote us some actual weights of your brass and aluminum carriers? I have 2 aluminum and 3 lightened brass and I can't see where you could remove enough brass to get them close to being the same in weight. Your correct, can’t come close to a aluminum carrier in weight. Stock weight for a .38 brass carrier is 3.7 oz, the weight for the same carrier after being milled by Cody Conagher Is 2.9 oz, the weight for a Cowboy & Indian’s .38 aluminum carrier is .98 oz. If one shoots 5 matches a month for all 12 months it would be 7,200 rounds. Close to 3 years for 20,000 rounds. Replacing the aluminum carrier for $75 every three years is cheap compared to the other costs in this game. Edited May 11 by Caboose 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Kid Rich 959 Posted May 11 Share Posted May 11 That would be on the low end of the scale of what we shoot. kR Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Caboose 154 Posted May 11 Share Posted May 11 2 minutes ago, Kid Rich said: That would be on the low end of the scale of what we shoot. kR Okay, once a year replacement is still cheap maintenance for the sport. Not many shooters average 5 matches a month 12 months a year in Minnesota, Wisconsin. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
bgavin 2,025 Posted May 11 Share Posted May 11 If the aluminum wears down fast, how many of those 20k rounds are affected by the gradual wearing out of the carrier? Quote Link to post Share on other sites
irish ike, SASS #43615 1,416 Posted May 11 Share Posted May 11 I've been running an aluminum carrier in my 73 for 12 years. A bit of wear on the edges where the case comes out. But still solid. 2 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Von Dutch, SASS # 7995 166 Posted May 11 Share Posted May 11 I have two 73's in 45LC and they have Cowboy & Indian aluminum carriers in them and they are over 15 years old and they have over 40,000 rds on them each and they still look great and work great! 2 2 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Go West 521 Posted May 12 Share Posted May 12 I have a C&I aluminum carrier in my '73 that is more than 15 years old. It has years more life in it. 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Matthew Duncan 1,702 Posted May 12 Share Posted May 12 On 5/10/2021 at 11:23 AM, Snake-eye, SASS#45097 said: I may have to replace the brass carrier on my .44 rifle before to long. Debating an aluminum one vs. a skeltonized brass which is what’s in there now. Looking for opinions and experiences. What caused your carrier to "wear out"? Asking because mine is 20 years old and I'd hate to have it break because I didn't check for? Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Snake-eye, SASS#45097 95 Posted May 12 Author Share Posted May 12 The area that the lifter rides on and pushes up on the carrier is thin and showing a slight bulge. I believe that’s the way it came not excessive wear. At some point the thin brass will fail, that’s why I plan to replace it. I’m going to go with brass replacement. Anybody got one they would sell? Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Garrison Joe, SASS #60708 3,186 Posted May 12 Share Posted May 12 My main match 73 in .45 Colt has 15 years of moderate use. And a C&I aluminum carrier since I short stroked it within 6 months of getting it. I'd guess 60,000 rounds through it with Cowboy and Wild Bunch both. Got lotsa life still in it. good luck, GJ 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
bgavin 2,025 Posted May 12 Share Posted May 12 Which make of brass carrier is the favored one for the 1873 Uberti? Mine is box stock at this time. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Snake-eye, SASS#45097 95 Posted May 12 Author Share Posted May 12 They are typically supplied with the rifle from the manufacturer. Skeletonizing just cuts away some of the brass in none essential areas to lighten it. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.