H. K. Uriah, SASS #74619 Posted October 4, 2025 Posted October 4, 2025 Anyone know where I can get a replacement cylinder for a Pietta copy of the SAA? Quote
Abilene, SASS # 27489 Posted October 4, 2025 Posted October 4, 2025 VTI, EMF, Taylor's, Cimarron 2 Quote
Blackwater 53393 Posted October 4, 2025 Posted October 4, 2025 Abilene has it covered pretty well! You could put an ad in the classifieds, but the above retailers will probably be quicker. 1 Quote
No Horse Hair, SASS #77464 Posted October 5, 2025 Posted October 5, 2025 I noticed awhile back Numrich arms has a few pieces for cowboy guns. VTI is great to work with.....they answer or call you back and and talk to you like back in the old days! 3 Quote
Texas Jack Black Posted October 5, 2025 Posted October 5, 2025 18 hours ago, H. K. Uriah, SASS #74619 said: Anyone know where I can get a replacement cylinder for a Pietta copy of the SAA? VTI for 180-200 depending on caliber and finish Quote
Colorado Coffinmaker Posted October 5, 2025 Posted October 5, 2025 There are some reputable "breakers" on eBay as well. You should screen the part for "Unused." Quote
TN Mongo, SASS #61450 Posted October 5, 2025 Posted October 5, 2025 One of my match Piettas has a Colt 2nd generation Cylinder in it. The original Pietta cylinder started over rotating. My gunsmith diagnosed as poorly milled bolt slots in the cylinder. I found several 2nd gen Colt cylinders on Ebay at far more reasonable prices than a new Pietta cylinder. My gunsmith had no trouble at all fitting it to my Pietta. It's worked wonderfully for the last 7 years. 1 Quote
TN Mongo, SASS #61450 Posted October 5, 2025 Posted October 5, 2025 You didn't mention what caliber you were looking for. I just looked on Ebay and there were several .357 and .38 cylinder available at very reasonable prices. The .45 LC ones were a lot more "pricey". Remember, third gen Colt cylinders will not work in a Pietta. Quote
H. K. Uriah, SASS #74619 Posted October 5, 2025 Author Posted October 5, 2025 What about a first generation cylinder? I have read that they are the same as seconds. Quote
TN Mongo, SASS #61450 Posted October 6, 2025 Posted October 6, 2025 There was a 10 degree (below centerline) change to the ratchet timing between the first and second generation cylinders. I know that the second generation cylinders are almost exactly the same as the Pietta cylinders. There are of course small differences between all cylinders that require fitting by a knowledgeable gunsmith. I gave my gunsmith 3 different Colt 2nd gen cylinders to try and one out of the 3 required no adjustment to work. He stated that he could have gotten the other two to fit with minor modifications. I'm not a gunsmith; I'm not sure if he could have gotten a first gen cylinder to work. I do know that first generation cylinders, in good condition, are a lot more expensive. 1 Quote
Sawhorse Kid Posted October 7, 2025 Posted October 7, 2025 I get all my parts for Taylors & Co. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.