Jump to content
SASS Wire Forum

Savvy Jack

Members
  • Posts

    956
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Posts posted by Savvy Jack

  1. On 12/1/2023 at 3:05 PM, Garrison Joe, SASS #60708 said:

    Those pictures are very similar to when a seating die is turning the crimp into the bullet BEFORE the seater depth has been fully reached.  As in, bullet continues to be shoved in the case AFTER the crimp has come down to bullet diameter.    Thus, the mouth shaves lead from that point on. 

     

    First, you are belling a little too much.   Because there is a gap in picture between the bullet base and, and the brass at the mouth.   You could close that up a hair and eliminate your first reported problem that the case will not by hand enter the seating die fully.

     

    Second, it seems the crimp ring in the die is turning in the mouth BEFORE your bullet has reached desired depth of seating.   Can you back off the body of the die so that NO crimp is applied, seat a bullet to right spot, then back off the STEM and run the BODY of the die of the die down to make the crimp you want, then run the STEM back down to touch the nose of bullet with that cartridge in the die, so you get the seating stem real close to the proper seating depth again.

     

    Are you SURE you don't have a bunch of dried lube stuck in the die below the original crimp ring?   Cleaned the die body with solvent and a brush yet? 

     

    This is a combined seat/crimp die, right?   Difficulties like this is why loading .44-40 is normally done with a seater die, then a crimp die.

     

    good luck, GJ

    what he said!

  2. Aside from Sidalia Daves Dillon issues....

     

    I used the Lyman "M" die to prevent shaving and seating issues common to the 44-40.

     

    44-40 "M" die for .427 or smaller

    44 Magnum "M" die for .428 and larger

     

    B.jpg.a757e8ab84ab05f7a6fa9e7fea67c008.jpg

     

    ed934edf-ff5d-4824-8c15-df8e662f94b9.__CR00970600_PT0_SX970_V1___.jpg.4d06e68e68128f6583abc3ad7fd2db51.jpg

    • Like 1
    • Thanks 1
  3. Winchester cases?

    Winchester cases are a bit more "elastic" than Star Line cases. This can cause the bellow to shrink back down too small for .429/.430 lead as the bullet seats bast the base or first driving band and down into the lube groove, hitting and skinning the next driving band or bullet shank. Sometimes just a shave, others it dug all the way into the foreword driving band.

     

    119457189_1592825804231330_2821257153820136535_n.jpg.4c410704fab59a1d8783aa4cf517baec.jpg

    119484190_1592779117569332_8933099032817916261_n.thumb.jpg.577e436d8bd822996adb274c830118b4.jpg

     

    • Sad 1
  4. We get some good fires in North Carolina too...

     

    Mark Carr photo (Collett Ridge Fire, Nov 6th) Total Size, 5,505 acres)

    398983996_10230274108178698_382012610872048417_n.thumb.jpg.cbd7f10054ee1a7e43ba11a25037d7dc.jpg

     

    Mark Carr photo (Collett Ridge Fire, early days, Oct 25th) 52 acres

    395751409_10230212253232363_843858237158549565_n.thumb.jpg.dc6212e7057045e9131fa22da627004f.jpg

    • Like 1
    • Thanks 2
  5. 53 minutes ago, Palouse said:

    How soft is that Hornady swedged bullet?  Did it lead up the barrel? Did you try it with BP?

    Tks.


    I never did test the hardness nor did I see it advertised. It is a 44 Mag bullet so it must be at least 16?  I never did try it with BP either...that could be interesting...hmmmmm

  6. I used said 240gr load back in 2017. I shot (poor shot placement) a Carolina swamp deer at 65-70 yards. The 1,350fps Hornady 240gr SWC HP entered high shoulder left side shot, hit the shoulder blade area, turned 90 degrees and traveled for a total of about  two and a half feet (30") down the spinal cord destroying everything in it's path...including a lot of good meat. It came to rest in the right hind quarter. The deer never took a step of which I was pleased by not having to chase it in the dark.......but it was a bit overkill!!!!

    I do honestly believe that load was good for larger game at that distance.

     

    IMG_2138.JPG

    IMG_2149.JPG

     

     

    25gr is a tad bit more than published (23.4) but plenty safe for the Marlin 1894CB

    IMG_2156.JPG

    Img_2423.jpg

    Img_2424.jpg

  7. 26 minutes ago, H. K. Uriah, SASS #74619 said:

    Factory loads should be find for deer or smaller.   In a 92 or, you could "hot rod" the round to much higher performance if you want too for use on larger game.

    I'd use it for deer, but nothing more than that.

     

    I have no reason to believe the higher velocity loading was for "larger" game. Just my opinion but I think it was for a flatter trajectory for long/er distances.

    Like Charlie said, 

    Quote

    I have gotten my deer every year that I have used it.

     

    ...referring to the slower 200gr JSP

    Rather than hot-rodding the 200gr for "larger game", I'd  use the 240gr hard cast at a slower velocities between 1,200fps to 1,300fps. That already is 10% to 20% more "power" than the 200gr at the same velocities. This can be done with an Alliant 2005 published Reloder 7 load.

     

  8. On 3/28/2020 at 11:45 PM, Charlie T Waite said:

     

    FYI, this is a factory load of the only jacketed soft points I could find.  I purchased 1 box 9-10 years ago just for hunting.  I have gotten my deer every year that I have used it. and the only reason I know the stats is that is what is written on the box, I personally haven't shot them through my chronograph.  I didn't say you needed that load, just that it was what I used..  With proper shot placement a shotgun even in 2 3/4" slug 410 will drop a deer. 


    I figured as much when I saw the 1,190fps.  Winchester last offered their 1,310fps load in 1978 using what appears to be 12.5gr of a rifle powder with a mixture of ball and maybe flattened ball powder. The following year, 1979, Winchester offered the same cartridge but with the slower 1,190fps velocity. The powder used in the newly offered cartridge was 8gr of a disc like pistol powder. Winchester also notes that the new loading maintains 869fps @ 500 yards.

  9. 5 hours ago, Charlie T Waite said:

    +1  I've used a 200 Grain Soft-Point (SP) with a Muzzle Velocity of 1190 and done very well out to around 200-250 yards for white tail.  150-200 is best though.  I would say 250 would be the max for this load.

     

     

    Absolutely, contrary to popular belief, all one needs to kill a whitetail is 700fps impact velocity for a clean shot. Where the shooter hits them and how and at what distance is up to the shooter's capability. 

     

    Quote
    1978 was the last offering for the 1,310fps velocity. It was after 1938 that Winchester lost the 1,570fps High Velocity option and after this year that the 44-40 lost it's standard 1,310fps load. From here Winchester dropped the velocity to an advertised 1,190fps.
     
    1978 - Winchester-Western, Sporting Arms, Ammunition and Reloading Components catalog shows the White boxes with Western Red "X" and Winchester Yellow "X". The 44-40 (Oilproof) is listed for both rifle and revolvers. Listed as W4440 (Winchester) and 4440 (Western). Muzzle velocity is 1,310fps rifle and 975fps revolver.
     
    1979 - Winchester-Western, Sporting Arms and Ammunition catalog shows the White boxes with Western Red "X" and Winchester Yellow "X". The 44-40 (Oilproof) is listed for both rifle and revolvers. Listed as W4440 (Winchester) and 4440 (Western). Muzzle velocity has dropped from 1,310fps rifle to 1,190fps and from 975fps revolver to 860fps.

     

  10. On 12/10/2016 at 10:45 AM, Driftwood Johnson, SASS #38283 said:

    44-40 was always a Boxer primed round, but I do not know the actual powder capacity of the old balloon head rounds. I tend to doubt they actually carried 40 grains of powder. 200 grains seems to be the earliest bullet weight.

     

    I know this is an old topic and is about the 45 Colt but I must comment on the 44-40 statement.


    Don't shoot the messenger!!!!


    Actually the very early cartridges were copper and Milbank primed but didn't last long at all. The only known three boxes of Milbank Primed boxes contain brass boxer primed cartridges. It is even rumored that early cartridges were paper patched.

     

    Quote

    44-40 case artifacts excavated at the Little Bighorn battlefield between 1984-2004 are indicated to be these very early and rare Milbank primed cases. However, Scott notes that they MAY be Milbank or Boxer primed cases. He states..."These brass cases are centerfire and were primed with the Winchester-Milbank or Boxer type primers." ~Scott, 2006 Archaeological Mitigation Report, page 12)

     

    In a private email, Dr. Scott also told me that the early cartridge cases were made of Bloomfield Gilding metal (essentially hardened copper), but soon went to brass.  

    I as well as John Kort, have dissected several mid 1880's headstamped cases and found 40gr of bp with an average compression of .21" of the powder. I have also dissected an early or even pre-1880 unheadstamed cartridge and found it to contain a heeled bullet.

    It is well known that the 73' was used against Custer. It is also shown in Winchester's 1875 catalog that the early bullets had an exposed grease groove.   21 cases linked to 14 rifles were discovered on the Custer Battlefield from 1984 to 2006 but I have yet to be able to verify if they were Milbank Primed nor have any 44 Winchester bullets been confirmed found. It has also been said that many 44-40 cases were found off the battlefield on private property. 

     

    For those interested in photos and more information, visit https://www.44winchestercenterfirecartridges.com/

    • Thanks 2
  11. What a great topic with some of the most positive replies I have seen in a very ling time for this cartridge. 

    It is very hard to "replace" the original charge of BP along with the 427098 type lead bullet and maintain original ballistics. Those early original loads catapulted the lead projectile downrange at 1,245fps. The bullets were lubricated well enough to lob 30 shots 110 yards downrange and all hit inside a 4" circle without cleaning the barrel between shots (Doc Pardee 1875 Winchester catalog). It just didn't get much better than that. Even today shooters such as John Kort prove the ole cartridge and it's original ballistics consistently hitting steel javelina at 300 meters (but using a scope).  The purpose was to prove the rifle/cartridge, not the shooter's eye sight! Results from my gel testing days..."75/1 bullets penetrated 27” of clear gel and expanded to .528”..."The handgun loads gave velocities from 941-963 fps at 10 ft., perforated and exited the 32” gel block"...excerpts taken from an article by Ed Harris, bullets cast by John Kort and gel shot test by Bryan Austin. Proof the velocity does not have to be much to penetrate a typical white tail.

    Moving on up to modern factory/handload cartridges...modern velocities are about 1,190fps, still well plenty enough to knock down a white tail but accuracy plummets in many cases out to and past 100 yards.  In addition to many
    firearm's differences in barrel sizes, tolerances, projectile weights and other sizes piled up on top of a somewhat finicky to load cartridge....the 44-40 has achieved a very unfair but understandable bad reputation.

    When a person begins to understand all of these issues, learns to adapt and overcome, a whole new world will open up. The 44-40 is actually a very multifaceted cartridge. From shotshells, round ball "game getters", 180gr XTP coyote loads to 240gr deer loads...from 50 yards to 300 yard options....decisions on a load can be almost endless not to mention the fact that you are enjoying a classic rifle cartridge and firearms that most modern weapons can not compete with. Lets don't forget the revolvers too.

    Now we get to the good stuff.....

     

    A little food for thought...pay close attention...because my writing skills remind me of a song by Allen Jackson !!
     

    Looking at Lyman's reloading manual #49 page 299, (Double check my numbers) Lyman lists several powders and charges for the 44-40. In particular, Lyman lists 2400 powder in use with the Speer 200gr JSHP bullet #4425. Lyman uses a 24" Universal receiver with 1:36" twist for these particular tests. Cases trimmed to 1.295 and an AOL of 1.600. Those measurements (plus some misc measurements) with Starline brass, using QuickLoad...gives a bullet seating depth of .313" as well as the pressures noted.

     

    Lyman Manual....vs...QL (Quickload) Data

    grains/powder/velocity/cup/QL psi CIP

     

    Group I Rifles (weak actions)(Lyman lists ten rifles).....That's nineteen different firearms total chambered for the 44-40 
    xxgr/2400/1,183fps/11,900/15,000 (fps=Current Factory VelocitiesNormal Loads

     

    Group II Rifles (strong actions)(Lyman lists nine rifles).....That's nineteen different firearms total chambered for the 44-40 
    xxgr/2400/1,380fps/14,500/19,000 (fps=Original Historical Velocities+P Loads due to higher than max pressures
    xxgr/2400/1,638fps/19,000/25,753 (fps=1903 (1910) Factory "High Velocity" Replication+P+ Loads due to excessive high pressure

     

    Lyman also lists Unique and IMR4227 powders for Group II Rifles

    Personally I will not shoot anything in my Marlin with CIP estimated pressures over 26,000psi CIP, we all have our limitations right?. My goal was to replicate the 1903, more yet...the 1910 "High Velocity" ballistics....not to try and make the 44-40 into a 44 magnum as so I have been accused. I consider these HV loads as 44-40 "+P+" loads for those that like to use the "+P" status.

     

    Reputable writers have been using and publishing the +P type loads that replicate original 1,300fps velocities ( but higher than black powder pressures) in magazines and online articles for years.

     

    For all the nay sayers, dudes, weekend range worriers and city slickers.....the loads are right there in the reloading manual!!

     

    Not in Lymans #49 but is in #47 is the 240gr lead bullet information and Reloder 7 that produce 1,200fps at "Group I" rifle category pressures. The same info is/was listed on Lee's 44-40 reloading 3-die-set pamphlet.

     

    Although the modern 1,300 fps velocities replicate original velocities using both black powder and early smokeless powder, the modern pressures generated are above SAAMI/CIP max pressures. I call modern 1,300fps velocities +P loads because of the higher than standard pressures of the earlier black powder and smokeless powder ballistics. The 1,400fps-1,600fps step in velocities I call +P+ loads.

    Again not trying to make the 44-40 into a 44 magnum....simply just trying to get that projectile downrange accurately and maintain enough energy to knock down that white tail :-)


    CIP vs SAAMI
     

    • Thanks 1
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.